Skip to content
NOWCAST Maine's Total Coverage At 6
Live Now
Advertisement

Former detective weighs in on lack of information surrounding death of Maine paddleboarder

Forensic science professor and former Connecticut State Police major crimes detective says investigators may be withholding information for strategic reasons

Former detective weighs in on lack of information surrounding death of Maine paddleboarder

Forensic science professor and former Connecticut State Police major crimes detective says investigators may be withholding information for strategic reasons

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:00
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
      BLUMENBERG DESCRIBES STEWARTS AS SOMEONE WHO LIVED "UNAPOLOGETICALLY ALIVE"... WHILE THE INVESTIGATION INTO WHAT HAPPENED TO SUNNY CONTINUES -- THE COMMUNITY SAYS THEY'RE FRUSTRATED WITH THE LACK OF COMMUNICATION FROM STATE POLICE. WE SPOKE WITH DR. PETER VALENTIN -- A FORENSIC SCIENCE PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW HAVEN AND FORMER MAJOR CRIMES DETECTIVE WITH THE CONNECTICUT STATE POLICE. HE SAID - IN HIS EXPERIENCE -- THERE'S AN INVESTIGATIVE ADVANTAGE THAT OFFICIALS WANT TO MAINTAIN BY WITHHOLDING INFORMATION. IT COULD BE SOMETHING COMPLETELY INCONSISTENT WITH A WATER RELATED DEATH, OR IT COULD BE SOMETHING COMPLETELY CONSISTENT WITH A WATER RELATED DEATH. BUT THERE WAS A SPECIFIC PIECE OF PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT LINKS HER TO A PARTICULAR PERSON. I MEAN, IT'S JUST THERE'S TOO MANY THINGS. AND SO, YOU KNOW, AS A FORENSIC SCIENTIST, I'VE GOT TO BE SOMEWHAT RESTRAINED IN SAYING, I DON'T KNOW, BUT THERE'S A REASON.. VALENTIN SAYS ON
      WMTW logo
      Updated: 5:46 PM EDT Jul 16, 2025
      Editorial Standards
      Advertisement
      Former detective weighs in on lack of information surrounding death of Maine paddleboarder

      Forensic science professor and former Connecticut State Police major crimes detective says investigators may be withholding information for strategic reasons

      WMTW logo
      Updated: 5:46 PM EDT Jul 16, 2025
      Editorial Standards
      As the investigation into what happened to Sunshine 'Sunny' Stewart continues, very few details have been offered to members of the community from state police. Stewart was found dead around 1 a.m. on Thursday, July 3, on Crawford Pond in Union. Maine State Police ruled her death a homicide, but have not released how she died. Dr. Peter Valentin, a forensic science professor at the University of New Haven and a former major crimes detective with the Connecticut State Police, says investigators may be withholding information for strategic reasons.“Generally, there's some investigative advantage that you want to maintain when you're withholding information,” Valentin told Maine's Total Coverage. “It could be something completely inconsistent with a water-related death, or it could be something completely consistent with a water-related death, but there was a specific piece of physical evidence that links her to a particular person. I mean, there's just too many things, and so as a forensic scientist, I’ve got to be somewhat restrained in saying, ‘I don’t know,’ but there’s a reason,” he said.He added that once the official cause of death is released, “things will likely start to make sense.” On Monday, July 14, Maine State Police spokesperson Shannon Moss explained why the agency has not shared more information."At this time, we are not releasing the cause of death, as doing so could compromise the integrity of the investigation. Detectives continue to follow up on all leads, and tips are still coming in. Detectives are actively pursuing every avenue, and we will provide updates when it’s appropriate and responsible to do so," Moss wrote.

      As the investigation into what happened to Sunshine 'Sunny' Stewart continues, very few details have been offered to members of the community from state police.

      Stewart was found dead around 1 a.m. on Thursday, July 3, on Crawford Pond in Union.

      Advertisement

      Maine State Police ruled her death a homicide, but have not released how she died.

      Dr. Peter Valentin, a forensic science professor at the University of New Haven and a former major crimes detective with the Connecticut State Police, says investigators may be withholding information for strategic reasons.

      “Generally, there's some investigative advantage that you [officials] want to maintain when you're withholding information,” Valentin told Maine's Total Coverage. “It could be something completely inconsistent with a water-related death, or it could be something completely consistent with a water-related death, but there was a specific piece of physical evidence that links her to a particular person. I mean, there's just too many things, and so as a forensic scientist, I’ve got to be somewhat restrained in saying, ‘I don’t know,’ but there’s a reason,” he said.

      He added that once the official cause of death is released, “things will likely start to make sense.”

      On Monday, July 14, Maine State Police spokesperson Shannon Moss explained why the agency has not shared more information.

      "At this time, we are not releasing the cause of death, as doing so could compromise the integrity of the investigation. Detectives continue to follow up on all leads, and tips are still coming in. Detectives are actively pursuing every avenue, and we will provide updates when it’s appropriate and responsible to do so," Moss wrote.